Like many Jean episodes, this had potential. So did the recent The Wayz We Were and Mothers and Others Strangers, but it's always the execution that screws his stories up. Here we spend too long at the Harry Potter World Ripoff in the beginning, when we could've just gone straight to Maggie needing to be baptized. It's fine to have an Act 1 that's meaningless, but it's just constant Harry Potter jokes that seem like cheap and small jabs. When we finally get to the Maggie baptized stuff, it feels rushed, like they thought they could just throw in a Flander's joke and move on to the next task of having Homer find a godfather. Just a note, but the animation was great this episode. Loved some of the visuals in Marge's dream, like the way the devil grabbed Maggie or when Bart was steering Homer around at the Harry Potter ride. Anyway, I thought Homer finding godfathers was cute with him immadetialy ruling out everyone in the bar within a couple of seconds, but when we finally get to the Fat Tony stuff it's all just very boring. Marge and Homer wanting Fat Tony to not be Maggie's godfather never did anything unique to progress the story. They just constantly kept telling him, no, and he just kept creeping back in as Maggie's godfather. There was no progression to that story and just felt like nothing. If I remember correctly was there even a reason Fat Tony wanted to be Maggie's godfather, cause I don't remember one. Anyway, I was thinking to myself how much of a b*tch Marge was being to Fat Tony, and it seemed very out of character for her. I know Marge can sometimes get pissed off like at the other Springfield Housewives, but I feel Marge would've let Fat Tony off the hook more quietly and subtly. The side plot with Fat Tony's fellow mob members also was just nothing. Like it felt like it was building up to something cool, and then Johnny Tightlips was then just betrayed by Legs and Louie. It just wrapped up too quickly, like it was checking off boxes. Did Marge tell Tony off? Did the plan to kill Tony go bad? Did Tony stop building his store? Did Tony stop being Maggie's godfather? I'm sorry if you liked this one, but I absolutely dreaded it. The only things I liked were the animation (which I mentioned above) and some of the interactions between Fat Tony and Maggie were very cute. 2/5