Rate and Review South Park: "1%"

How would you rate this episode?


  • Total voters
    21

Oh that's raspberry!

Food-Crazed Maniac
Joined
Apr 29, 2011
Messages
17,824
Location
Pennsylvania
Alright I missed the first 2 acts earlier but just caught them. I really didn't care for anything regarding the 99% or whatnot. Cartman's story was better but not great. Kinda dissapointed really. Still it was entertaining enough and had a few good one-liners so I guess 3/5.

Also, Stan's voice sounded really off in the first 2 or so acts to me.
 

Ryan

hoot
Joined
Sep 28, 2002
Messages
21,307
Location
Las Vegas, NV
Fun episode, and although their OWS message is somewhat muddled but not surprising (i.e. it's all bullshit), lot of laughs and an awesome twist Cartman ending that reminded me somewhat of Scott Tenorman.

Also noticed Stan's voice was a little off.
 

Gatorgod

AddminisGator
Joined
Sep 5, 2005
Messages
5,359
Location
Swamptopia
:gatorshrug: dunno, I wasn't feeling it to much this time..
Liked the extra sampling of Cartmans schizophrenia, not in his hand this time. His mothers nervous giggle at the end was top notch!
 

Mr. Krikt

Pin Pal
Joined
Dec 1, 2008
Messages
575
South Park has become the sort of show you leave on in the background, it's that boring. It did catch my attention when it showed and namedropped Arkham City though. Why was that?

There used to be a novelty to South Park parodying fairly recent events, especially compared to the likes of the Simpsons which parodies a movie two years old. The problem with this episode is that it just simply isn't interesting enough.
 

Train on the Water

Boat on a track
Joined
Jan 22, 2005
Messages
3,334
I feel like it's been a very solid run so far (other than Broadway, which I haven't seen yet). We've been seeing much less of the South Park cliches we're used to, and more of the kids acting their ages and the school. I imagine we'll get a Stan or Kyle episode next week because there has been a lack of the two other than the half-season premiere. I missed the first act and really don't have a ton to say, but due to all the dissatisfaction despite what the poll ratings say, I just decided to pop in and say I enjoyed it. And this is an episode Matt and Trey have been working on since before Assburgers, so as a month-old script, it couldn't be too timely and heavy in case the Wall Street situation changed before the episode was even finished.

4/5
 
Z

Zombies Rise from the Sea

Guest
1%

This is the momentous episode that everybody has been waiting for, the "Matt & Trey's take on #OccupyWallStreet" episode. Even though other shows have taken a shot at the Occupy movement, we were waiting to see what Matt and Trey's take would be like, and this is it...

What I saw was moderately disappointing. It does start off with some interesting stuff about the presidential fitness test though. I appreciated how they snuck in something about not wanting the small percentage of people who failed the test to be singled out due to general fears of disappointment and failure... This is repeated throughout most of the first part and some of the rest of the episode but it usually lacks impact the second time around due to well, us getting the jists of what they were implying in the beginning. I do have to say that this works for getting the plot off the ground and providing some of the Occupy satire but aside from that, the whole presidential fitness test doesn't amount to much.

The other interesting thing that might hook viewers is the seminal focus on Cartman, who is singled out for being the obvious 1% who affected the entire school. I have to admit, Cartman's antics were a bit by-the-numbers disappointing. I mean how many times have you heard him rip on poor people and jews and defend his fatness do it better... (That 9/11 quip was funny but still, could of been done better.) The moment where the dolls start getting torn to bits does up the quality levels a bit (if not for the mystery and the reaction he's getting.) it was kind of interesting to watch his dolls get murdered one by one and to have him react in a fearful way like a horror movie... The addition of the 5th graders and the bait and switch gag worked well for throwing off the audience (including me) to the ultimate resolution of the episode.

Unfortunately that moment is somewhat ruined by the ending which is mainly due to my lack of understanding of it. I mean it's portrayed as if Cartman had somehow manipulated the whole situation (like he did with Scott Trenorman and well, Jenifer Lopez) of "Princess Polly as a murderer" as a way to get rid of his dolls so he can "grow up"... (I don't know how he'd be able to set his own room on fire but, I degress... I mean if Mr. Hat can come to life, maybe Polly Princess can do the same.) Some people may think of that ending as a "character growth" and a "breaking of a character's perception" but I think otherwise (more on that later...) What I do think of it as is an ending reminiscent of Scott Tenorman and other episodes like that... What with it's overly dramatic overtones and the reaction from the people watching it; some people may be expecting for this to be added to Cartman's character in future episodes but I don't think it's going to turn out that way...

The Occupy satire takes up half of the episode and as I said before, it's moderately disapointing. For one, their take on it is muddy; I mean "Sunny" parodied the sudden need for democracy as well as their supposed unitation on one subject when they all had multiple views, plus the backstabbing aspect of it all. This parody focuses on the massive news coverage that has surrounded the Occupy movements as well as the large crowds, the anarchy as well as the police response to it. The reference to Red Robin did surprise me at first but without any explanation (not even a response saying "they've been charging more and it just hasn't been the same before"), it just became a menial backdrop to show how bullshit the Occupy protests are, the newscasting person had some funny moments and the way the 5th graders joined in was funny but it just ended without much resolution, even the police were scared of a riot yet they did nothing to stop it or even respond to it really... I don't know what they were trying to mock with that but I think it went over my head. (Side Note: I did notice they finally acknowledged Anonymous's presence, I'm guessing their years of referencing South Park has finally payed off...)

Ultimately, the long-expected parody/satire we've been waiting for turns out to be a bust. We get some funny moments and some clever satire but this isn't interesting in the least bit; it feels by-the-numbers, which is odd even though they've included some unique stuff in the episode. Something which feels by-the-numbers despite the originality definitely raises the oddity part by 10,000 fold... As something like that should never happen, but it did... For an episode of this caliber, it felt like it had something more to say but ultimately didn't say it.

6.0/10

EPILOGUE: One of the things I detest about episodes like these is that there is usually one reviewer who over analyzes the episode and focuses more on looking for signs then just watching the episode and deciding whether or not he likes it or not... That person usually wants to be teaching philosophy in a college but usually lacks the individuality or the defiance needed to ask those questions... That person is Ryan McGee from the A.V. Club.

That is evident when he describes a review is more than just deciding whether or not it's funny... That a review is a statement and a subjective one at that. I can understand the thing about humor being subjective but he's talking about the plot using complex cinematic techniques and talking about Cartman's plot as if it was changing the face of literacy as we know it. I mean "transcending", "profoundness", he's just an 8 year old kid without a father... And with wrong viewpoints about almost everything...

I mean you go on about how he knew Cartman for 15 seasons and how he had to alter his native state to change himself yet Cartman was not just known for the outlandish viewpoints he incorporated into his persona. (The outlandish stuff came way later in the show's run.) Initially, he was just an 8 year old kid with delusions of grandier, incorrect perceptions of nearly everything (though oddly enough, he was right about most of the stuff such as Token being able to play a bass guitar) and a state of wanting everything that he saw... He was the rare kid that despite insulting his friends, managed to keep them. The talking with dolls thing was his way of connecting with who he created as people like him, people who thought he was cool and awesome... The outlandish viewpoint stuff well... I don't know where he got that but I do know that the current viewpoint thing is built into the show itself, Cartman is not the only one who has this; Kyle, Stan and Kenny has had the current viewpoint thing at one time or another...

The stuff about Cartman wanting to change is somewhat diluted by the fact that there were points where he had the chance, things such as the fat camp (which contains another show of Cartman's character when he eats after he's dejected from the camp), the time he was in Africa, the time where he was in certain moments of isolation and unfamilarity. Those moments allowed him to rethink his life for a second and well, opted to change his life for a minute but I guess the sitcom boomerang comes back around. Cartman wasn't the one who ignored change (well maybe in that Wendy episode) but didn't even have the thought occur in his head that he needed changing, possibly because of her mother smothering him to death. (She was the one who told him he was fat boned after all.)

Additionally, the toys being a major part of Cartman growing up is also diluted by one simple thing, we barely see Cartman play with his dolls in the way that you describe or well, ever... We've had the tea party thing in the first season, we've had a mention of him in the episode where Cartman get's cancer and we've even seen them in an odd game which Cartman plays with Bebe. The way Cartman's plays with the dolls is too inconsistent to support the theory of them being a major part of Cartman's not growing up, I mean it'd be good if we've had more consistent evidence throughout the 15 seasons but there isn't and because of that, it doesn't hold up that much merit.

And what's with this "It’s a trick that South Park could pull off in the way that Lost pulled off a certain trick at the end of its third season. By using audience expectations against them". I mean "audience expectations", what kind of expectations would we have about Cartman. I mean as I mentioned before, he is an 8-year old boy. And the thing about the Lost Season 3 finale doesn't match up with South Park. "Though the Looking Glass" played off the expectation that Jack would be happy when everybody was rescued and that the stuff we were seeing in the flashforwards happened in the past, but it turned out to be the reverse... Cartman on the other hand (except for a few denials of his weight and life.) doesn't have the same kinds of expectations as "Through the Looking Glass". Hell we've seen episodes where he could be either malicious, unaware of what's going on or fully aware of what's going on but not doing it maliciously... It's also noted throughout the 15 seasons that Cartman did not try to be cool until much, much later; he also didn't have a KFC addiction and a even more pissed off temper then ever before, with the speech of a political rebel fighting against authority... So the Cartman we've come to known and love is too inconsistent for us to have "expectations".

It's obvious that nobody can figure out how Cartman's mind works exactly; why he does the stuff that he does... However, this overanalysis of Cartman in this recent episode without an exact knowledge of the 15 seasons only serves to defer Cartman's actions in the past 15 seasons and futher mudel Cartman's character as a whole. I know that you'd like to be taken seriously when reviewing South Park episodes but this type of analysis helps nobody, it's just entertainment.

Also you should really stop looking for signs of change that you were promised. I know that the episode tempted you with change and those signs of change are interesting because it changed the whole dynamic of South Park but we've had these changes before and I predicted that the changes would be reverted after a long time or so... Granted I didn't expect that it'd be reverted in the episode after that but still, we've got had. There is no use searching for any changes after an episode promised you the changes earlier; it serves no purpose whatsoever and only leads to the overanalysis of episodes like this one... Just thought I should let you know Mr. Ryan.
 
Last edited:

Redem

Pin Pal
Joined
Apr 5, 2009
Messages
548
That was one of the better episode I've seen in a long time, although I wasn't quite suprise by the final twist it still a very good episode
 

TriforceBun

*RIP Marcia Wallace*
Joined
Sep 12, 2004
Messages
3,023
Location
Louisiana
I'm a bit out of the loop, so the 99% stuff wasn't particularly enticing to me. That said, there were several solid jokes throughout that run, including the role of the fifth graders and Butters occupying the restroom (along with some fun "movement" wordplay). The real highlight for me was Cartman's story, which escalated into a genuinely mysterious and creepy tale (this would've been good on Halloween week), cleverly climaxing at Token's mansion-like house.

Taking a premise as simple as "Cartman decides to grow up a bit and get rid of his stuffed animals"--properly mentioned here and there in the episode by other characters--leads to the fat sociopath doing so in the most Cartman-like way possible. Some of my favorite episodes push the envelope in that way, and this was no exception. If the protesting subplot was a bit stronger and tied back into the main storyline better, this would easily be the best episode in a long time.

4/5 B+

That's four 4/5s in a row for South Park! Keep up the good work, gents.
 

Redem

Pin Pal
Joined
Apr 5, 2009
Messages
548
Small thing while him getting rid of his plush toy could be a step forward, they aren't exactly what was the wrongest part with him, I could see how they could get rid of them without really changing anything (at least in the short-term)

Oh well we have at least learn that there is exactly 100 student as south park elementary
 

Jayrayman

i did not hit her
Joined
Mar 7, 2005
Messages
1,191
I might be in the 1% (get it) but I thought that was one of the best South Park episodes I've ever seen. So yeah 5/5
 

DotheBartman

SuperFriend
Joined
Oct 17, 2001
Messages
6,150
Location
NYC
And this is an episode Matt and Trey have been working on since before Assburgers, so as a month-old script, it couldn't be too timely and heavy in case the Wall Street situation changed before the episode was even finished.

I would guess that a month ago it didn't have any Occupy stuff in it at all. I think it even had a different title, then. I would imagine they added the OWS stuff closer to when it actually aired, like over the last week basically.

Good episode. The OWS material was generally funny and clever if maybe not really saying much of anything in particular most of the time, but the whole Cartman story was just genius.
 

NoOneFamous

Wants you to do fine.
Joined
Mar 4, 2002
Messages
1,773
Location
Orlando, Florida
I enjoyed it, the OWS stuff was thankfully not too heavy-handed, and Cartman and his his stuffed animals were funny, though it did get old by the end.

4/5
 

Train on the Water

Boat on a track
Joined
Jan 22, 2005
Messages
3,334
I would guess that a month ago it didn't have any Occupy stuff in it at all. I think it even had a different title, then. I would imagine they added the OWS stuff closer to when it actually aired, like over the last week basically.

On the 60 Minutes special it was called "Crapped His Pants." So it's possible that the plots of Bass to Mouth and 1% were actually mixed together.
 

Dark Homer

pineapple shoes
Administrator
Joined
Oct 18, 2001
Messages
10,853
Location
geohell
Oh wow I forgot to put a space between the two words and you actually felt a need to bring that up when even Sarah Palin would be able to comprehend what television show I was referring to...sad mate.
zinger.jpg

ooh I'm going to say "ouch" for palin
 

Kiyosuki

Profound Sadness
Joined
Apr 17, 2006
Messages
4,411
Seems South Park's going through a bit of a Moral Orel phase at the moment, sort of deconstructing itself every chance it gets. The parallels to the current protests were eh...alright but everything about Cartman was pretty intense. Seems like the protest was put in there to not make it a total depression-fest, since the real meat was obviously Cartmans'. Like the Stan one a few months ago, it sort of feels like it doesn't even care about being funny about it. Kind of out the left field but I like it. I guess the best satire to do now is about itself, but that can be pretty good for a status quo heavy long-term show like this.
 

Diversity Pumpkin

Stonecutter
Joined
Nov 3, 2008
Messages
4,637
The meeting with his toys (where his mom comes in and sits down) was originally from 201. Instead Cartman was trying to figure out who his father was.
 
Z

Zombies Rise from the Sea

Guest
Seems South Park's going through a bit of a Moral Orel phase at the moment, sort of deconstructing itself every chance it gets.

I have to disagree. Morel Orel's deconstruction was much more pronounced and it actually effected the world around it (characters changed, he and his father grew apart, and much of that was carried throughout the large percentage of episodes in the third season.), most of the recent events have been placed within this episode and the last one; and it wasn't sort of the deconstruction that I was expecting. I mean what we did get was Cartman using these dolls for subsistence that played way for a Cartman plot involving his dolls getting murdered by himself while he remained unaware of what happened. (I mean even Cartman has forgotten about what happened earlier.) Granted he did realize that the dolls were preventing him from growing up but that was at the end of the episode and I'm not sure if it'll be added to future episodes, because of the way it was played out...
 

Redem

Pin Pal
Joined
Apr 5, 2009
Messages
548
On the 60 Minutes special it was called "Crapped His Pants." So it's possible that the plots of Bass to Mouth and 1% were actually mixed together.

I suppose the academical test they refer in Bass to Mouth we're suppose to be the starting instead of the Presidential fitness test
 

Irvine

Hired Goon
Joined
May 25, 2011
Messages
16,428
The jokes were good, but it was poorly written overall. The plot twist of this made no sense at all. A mediocre episode. 5.5/10

P.S. Is it just this or was Liane's voice a little different-sounding in this episode?
 
Joined
Feb 1, 2009
Messages
3,303
Location
UK
Predictable, but ok episode.

First episode in ages that I've seen Kenny doing something in a scene (climbing rope in gym).

3/5
 

Sam

Global Moderator
Global Moderator
Joined
Oct 2, 2010
Messages
36,487
Location
Pennsylvania
Predictable, but ok episode.

First episode in ages that I've seen Kenny doing something in a scene (climbing rope in gym).

3/5
Haven't been following this show in a while, so what, is Kenny doing nothing nowadays?
 

Walid

Executive Vice President
Joined
Jun 8, 2009
Messages
27,267
Location
'cause I live at home in a trailer...
this was pretty good. the twist ending was really interesting. the scenes with butters and jimmy definitely had more humor but Cartman had a better plot. 4/5 or so would be my grade
 
Top