Rate and Review : Homer vs. the Eighteenth Amendment

What do you think of this episode?

  • 2/5 This isn't the world's worst episode. What about that freezer lady in Georgia?

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 1/5 From now on, the writers should stick to smuggling heroin.

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    147
(first to write here in 3 years)

Act 1 - What are you looking at, jerks?:gatordrunk:
Act 2 - Genius (said sarcastic and honestly in the same time:))
Act 3 - One of the best status quo return:D

The drunk topic is always sleezy, especially, if saying about "dry law":D The episode should be better, perhaps, by adding with more memorable moments, and more "clever" twists development.

I appreciated the parody on "government wrong law" in the view of Rex Banner and his disability to see the obvious Beer Baron (it's HOMER:D). I really laughed of these manifestations.

Homer's scheme was cartoonish, but really impressed (even Marge appreciated it).
I think, my scores will tell about the episode better, than I did.:oops:|

plot 16/25
absurdity level (the possibility of what is happening) 19/25
comedy 16/25
originary (level of references and of unoriginality) 22/25

TOTAL 73/100 (3/5, down from 3.5, with rounding or B-). OK!
IMHO, the 3rd worst episode in season 8 (in my personal list) (unpopular opinion, but I don't care see the end of my signature. In fact the 73 is shared by several eps. in the season, but this one has the worst story part)
 
This episode is (along with Beer) the solution to all of our problems. A fun episode with an interesting plot has to be in my top ten (or 5) Season 8 episodes. 5/5.
 
Back
Top