I haven't actually listened to Alchemy yet, but I'd probably rank them Brothers In Arms(Love every track except ride across the river)>Love Over Gold>Dire Straits>Making Movies>On Every Street>Communique
I never really understood the fuss made over making movies, only tracks i like are romeo and juliet, tunnel of love and hand in hand, rest is mediocre. Also Communique is probably the only album I don't like. Only tracks that appeal to me are Where Do You Think You're Going and maybe Lady Writer.