1010011010
Remember Me As I Was
Nastyfacts
i was thinking about this and kind of the randomness of the matchups and wanted to throw out there a different system for next time. keep the rounds essentially the same as they currently are, only instead of assigning 1-on-1 matchups, just have people pick half of them to advance. so in round one for instance, you'd still get a list of 16 songs, but you'd just pick whichever 8 you want to advance. that way we'd avoid the inevitable "my two favorite songs of this round are matched up against each other" and songs advancing deep simply because they lucked into easy matchups (i'm not suggesting this was the case for either of these final songs, btw)
the downside of course would be that it would make it a little harder to vote, because you'd have to consider the songs as an entire group instead of simply picking between 2, but i dunno. just a thought
i was thinking about this and kind of the randomness of the matchups and wanted to throw out there a different system for next time. keep the rounds essentially the same as they currently are, only instead of assigning 1-on-1 matchups, just have people pick half of them to advance. so in round one for instance, you'd still get a list of 16 songs, but you'd just pick whichever 8 you want to advance. that way we'd avoid the inevitable "my two favorite songs of this round are matched up against each other" and songs advancing deep simply because they lucked into easy matchups (i'm not suggesting this was the case for either of these final songs, btw)
the downside of course would be that it would make it a little harder to vote, because you'd have to consider the songs as an entire group instead of simply picking between 2, but i dunno. just a thought
On a more personal issue, this sounds like an absolute nightmare to tally the votes for (compared to our current method). It would involve much closer inspection of the votes, plus it wouldn't necessarily be in any order for each post to look similar enough for tallying to be straightforward. And if there were any ties, tiebreakers would still have to be one v one from a person who hadn't voted yet.